Comments

Decay and Debatable Reasons: Armenian church crumbles in Georgia

In the early hours of Thursday, November 19, the Armenian St. George Church (Sourb Gevorg Church of Mughni) built in 1356, collapsed in Tbilisi.

St. George Church of Mughni is one of the five disputed churches which have become an issue of controversy between the Armenian Apostolic and Georgian Churches.

Reply

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. However, comments not pertaining to the topic or containing slander or offensive language will be deleted. You have to be registered to be able leave your comment. Sign in or Register now for free. See our Privacy Policy.
10
24.11.2009 12:28
yes I agree that Saakashvili imagines that Georgia is somewhere in the middle of Europe..he has encouraged Georgians to think that Armenia Azerbaijan and Russia are on the other side of the globe. Creating hostility with Armenia by attacking Armenian heritage in (what became ) Georgia is as foolish as provoking Russia
9
23.11.2009 05:12
Mike, did you hear the latest speech by president Sakashvilli? he is urging Georgians to learn Turkish and Chinese. He feels Georgia and the caucasus region is so developed that nationalism is to a minimum between the races. He is day dreaming that Georgia is bordering France or Belgium so they should learn the neighbors language. Sure, we all wish that everyone is so civilized in the caucasus, but the western-graduate president is very good in the short term for Georgia but strategically, in my opinion, he is a disaster to his country. He should attend one day the Turkic republics meetings and listens careful to what's going on...
8
22.11.2009 17:13
Mkrtich, of course this has "something to do with the Turks and the Genocide," common sense and politics dictates the ongoing happenings in Georgia. Well, assuming that Turkey and Armenia were forever friends, and that there was no indirect pressure on Georgia from Turkey and others, then Georgia would have prevented the demise of this beautiful old church. If you think that politics has nothing to do with this sad happening, then, you are dazed and dreaming. Why would Georgia confiscate ancestral churches of Armenians? Why would Georgia, like Turkey, allow the structural deterioration of these old churches? Is it because they hate Armenians? Is it because they envy our political situation? Of course not, the only reason they have neglecting our churches is because they want to show Turkey that Georgia can do anything it wants, and Armenians are powerless to stop them. Poor Georgians, their whole country is falling into pieces, and they are worried about Christian Armenians. On a recent trip to Georgia, visiting the Georgian villages east of Tblisi, I was shocked to see only Turkish speaking peoples there, no Georgian was to be found, what's more, the local Turks alleged that the eastern part of Georgia belongs to Azerbaizan. Selling Georgia for the greenbucks...sad, very sad indeed.
7
21.11.2009 07:30
This barbarism It would be wrong to think there is no “Christian Talibans” in the world! Either his H. the Georgian Catholicos needs the cross of this medieval Armenian Church to decorate his office or just Georgian president needs one more „cross” to put on the Georgian state flag- in order to have a “true Christian flag”!
6
21.11.2009 06:11
Mkrtich, In a sense you are correct. But, if the Georgian-Armenian diocese of the Armenian Apostolic Church is making the statement, don't you think that they know what the ACTUAL situation surrounding this and other related issues is? I think the issue is not that Georgia did "something" so the church collapsed, rather that Georgian authorities DID NOT do anything to prevent it (maybe along with the Armenian reps in that country, in case their hands were not tied up as in Turkey).
5
21.11.2009 00:58
We are making fools of ourselves by relating this to Turks and genocide. Is this the only way an Armenian can show grief? This church collapsing is extremely sad on its own right and it would seem appropriate to contemplate its loss as it is, a terrible unexpected event reminding us of the vulnerable nature of our heritage. This is not an appropriate occassion for starting self-victimizing anti-Georgian or anti-Turkish rants. Think of the people who built this church, I'm sure they would be offended to see their work used for hateful and resentful conspiracy theories.
4
20.11.2009 16:55
Sadly, Georgia is devouring itself, getting rid of any and all Armenian religeous and cultural monuments. Armenians are being replaced by Turks, who already make 22% of the total population of Georgia. Come 2047, when Turks make 65% of the total population of Georgia, and thus the beginning of the end of Georgia as we knew. Sad ending for a proud people whose leaders are out of greed are destroying Georgia. OK, take our churches, blow them up and see if you will last the next century.
3
20.11.2009 10:29
i cannot believe this story, not that it didn't happen...
2
20.11.2009 10:21
Shame on You, Georgia. jeshmarid2yahoo.com
1
20.11.2009 09:00
this is culture genocide by our christian Georgia!
Comments are welcomed and encouraged. However, comments not pertaining to the topic or containing slander or offensive language will be deleted.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><br><p>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.